| All-League Teams | ||||||
| Yr/Pos | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 |
| 1B | Robert Hays | Sam Honeck | Alex Gregory | Justin Bunkis | Charlie Yarbrough | Scott Hendrix |
| Beltway Blue Caps | Vienna Senators | Fairfax Nationals | Vienna Senators | Reston Hawks | Fauquier Gators | |
| St. Edwards) | Tulane University | Radford University | Loyola Marymount University | Longwood University | Kennesaw State University | |
| 2B | Dan Lopez | Steve Gauthe | Chris Anderson | Tim Guidry | Braxton Good | Will Rhymes |
| McLean Raiders | Vienna Senators | Herndon Braves | Vienna Senators | Herndon Braves | Arlington Senators | |
| Pitt | Copiah-Lincoln CC | University of Mary Washington | Tulane University | VMI | College of William & Mary | |
| 3B | Martin Parra | Nick Wheeler | Joe Lake | Ricky Owens | Ryan Strieby | Kelly Sweppenhiser |
| Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Herndon Braves | Fauquier Gators | Baltimore Pride | Vienna Mustangs | |
| UTAMCC | Itawamba CC | James Madison University | Belhaven College | Edmonds CC / Kentucky | VMI | |
| SS | Wade Kirkland | Robbie Shields | Anthony Scelfo | Guillermo Martinez | Matt Hill | Geoff Milsom |
| McLean Raiders | McLean Raiders | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Fauquier Gators | Vienna Mustangs | |
| Florida Southern | Florida Southern College | Tulane University | University of South Alabama | Elon University | George Washington University | |
| UTL | Nick Kurockzo | Jason Kitchen | Mike Bianucci | Rhett Teller | Mike Costanzo | |
| Vienna Senators | Bethesda Blue Caps | Reston Hawks | Herndon Braves | Bethesda Big Train | ||
| Utah | Connecticut College | Auburn University | St. Leo University | Coastal Carolina University | ||
| UTL | A.J. Kirby-Jones | |||||
| Fairfax Nationals | ||||||
| Tennesse Tech | ||||||
| DH | Shane Brown | Alex Gregory | John Mazzello | Ryan Mitchell | Brian LaNinfa | Brian LaNinfa |
| Beltway Blue Caps | Fairfax Nationals | Fauquier Gators | Fairfax Nationals | Bethesda Big Train | Bethesda Big Train | |
| UCF | Radford University | Marist University | Lipscomb University | Mississippi State University | Mississippi State University | |
| C | Max Eckert | Ty Boyles | Franco Valdes | Jason Bour | Mike McKenry | Jeff Speights |
| Beltway Blue Caps | Fairfax Nationals | Vienna Senators | Fairfax Nationals | Bethesda Big Train | Germantown Black Rox | |
| Stephenson | Gardner-Webb University | Broward County CC | Hampden-Sydney University | MTSU | Dartmouth College | |
| OF | David Harris | LaDale Hayes | Scott Lambert | Kellen Kulbacki | Brandon Bowser | Nate Southard |
| Vienna Senators | DC Grays | DC Grays | Herndon Braves | Herndon Braves | Arlington Senators | |
| Pepperdine | Alabama A&M University | Shenandoah University | James Madison University | James Madison University | Tulane University | |
| Juan Mujica | Juan Mujica | Emre Caglayan | Louis Ullrich | Drew Carson | Josh Outman | |
| DC Grays | DC Grays | Fairfax Nationals | Reston Hawks | Bethesda Big Train | Fauquier Gators | |
| Southern University | Southern University | Wofford College | Longwood University | University of Southern Mississippi | Forrest Park CC | |
| Chris Duffy | Drew Allain | Xavier Qualls | Donald Brown | Daniel Burton | Tyler Jones | |
| Beltway Blue Caps | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Bethesda Big Train | |
| UCF | Delgado CC | Southeastern LA University | Pepperdine University | University of Louisville | Mississippi State University | |
| Chris Briere | Ryan Eden | |||||
| Fairfax Nationals | Vienna Senators | |||||
| Longwood College | University of New Orleans | |||||
| Pitchers | Eric Cantrell | Aaron Loup LHP | Mason Griffin RHP | Bubba Blalock RHP | Adam Mills RHP | Cla Meredith RHP |
| Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Fauquier Gators | SS-T Thunderbolts | Arlington Senators | |
| George Washington | Tulane University | Grayson County CC | Kennesaw State University | UNC Charlotte | VCU | |
| Jay Joines | Gabe Rios RHP | John Zorich LHP | Scott Maine LHP | Jon Link RHP | Jason Mills RHP | |
| Beltway Blue Caps | Fairfax Nationals | Herndon Braves | Herndon Braves | Herndon Braves | Herndon Braves | |
| Richmond | Urbana University | University of Louisiana Lafayette | University of Miami | VCU | George Mason University | |
| Kyle Hald | Nate Newman RHP | Adam Olbrychowski RHP | Greg Holland RHP | Ryan Belanger RHP | Adam Daniels LHP | |
| Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Arlington Senators | |
| Old Dominion | Pepperdine University | Peppedine University | Western Carolina University | Copiah-Lincoln CC | Eastern Oklahoma State Univ | |
| Relief | Dan Tillman | Nick Schreiber RHP | David Kellerberg RHP | Keith Moreland RHP | Mike Billek RHP | |
| McLean Raiders | Fairfax Nationals | Vienna Senators | Bethesda Big Train | SS-T Thunderbolts | ||
| Florida Southern | California University at PA | Florida Southern University | UNC Charlotte | University of Central Florida | ||
| Jimmy Duggan | Mason Griffin RHP | Dustin Pease LHP | ||||
| Vienna Senators | Vienna Senators | Herndon Braves | ||||
| George Washington | Grayson CC | Mt. St. Marys University | ||||